Past Presidents of the HCS
- David Horan (2023- )
- Logan Grubb (2022-2023)
- Michael Proper (2018- 2022)
- David Horan (2015-2018)
- Michael Zerbe (2015)
- Glenn Murray (2011-2014)
- Anne Dunne-Hayes (2009-2010)
- Michael Zerbe (2005-2009)
- Claudia Dubaldi (2004-2005)
- Rev. Canon Calvin Van Kirk Hoyt (2001-2004)
- Richard Watson (1998-2000)
- Christina Jillard (1998)
- Tammy Marquardt (1996-1997)
- Alan C. Wenrich (1993-1996)
- Lauren Zaccarelli (1991-1993)
- Alan C. Wenrich (1989-1991)
- Geoff Coleman (1988-1989)
- William G. Wilson (1987-1988)
- Alan C. Wenrich (1985-1987)
- Polly Finan (1984)
- William G. Wilson (1982-1983)
- Judy Chronister (1980-1981)
- Aaron Spicher (1979)
- Carolyn Lauver (1978)
- Judy Chronister (1977)
- James Zeisloft (1976)
- Phylis S. Moffett (1974-1975)
- Roger W. Sieber (1973)
- Grace Laverty (1972)
- Ramon Yentzer (1971)
- Glenn Landis (1969-1970)
- Richard Schwan (1968)
- Albert Hoy (1967)
- Paul Hertzler (1965-1966)
- Phylis S. Bethards (Moffett) (1964)
- Martha Hoy (1963)
- Albert Hoy (1962)
- Bruce Whyte (1960-1961)
- Albert Zimmerman (1958-1959)
- R. Dean Souders (1957)
- Edward O. Keller (1956)
- Dr. C. Stanley Holmes (1954-1955)
- R. Dean Souders (1953)
- William K. Miller (1950-1952)
- R. Dean Souders (1949)
- Paul D. Kister (1948)
- Ruth M. Sweigart (1947)
- (unknown) (1946)
- Calvin R. Stafford (1945)
- (unknown) (1940-1944)
- William A. Sponsler III (1939)
- Robert Hall Craig (1937-1938)
- Dr. J. Horace McFarland* (1922-1931)
- John Fox Weiss, Esq. (1910-1916)
- Rt. Rev. James H. Darlington (1907-1909)
- The Reverend George S. Chambers (1895-1906)
* Chairman of May/Mozart Festivals, 1922-1933
